40 Comments
User's avatar
Nancy Kimelman's avatar

Warsh is not an economist who judges policy by the state of the economy. From what I have read he is more focused on institutions and the full array of public policies that affect the economy, of which monetary policy is but one. The fact that he believes that the policy rate as well as market rates should be down around 3% now should leave no doubt in which direction he will take the Fed and FOMC. In short, he's a political pick, not a financial or economic expert. Just a reminder: the best Fed Chairs were experts themselves: Volker, Greenspan, Bernanke, Yellen. If his history tells his story, he probably won't make that list. And the nation will be the worse for it.

AI8706's avatar

I don’t think that thinking of him as a hawk or a dove is productive. As Paul Krugman I think rightly put it, Warsh is a lapdog.

Thomas Hoenig was a hawk. I had disagreements about his views, but they were transparent and principled. But Warsh is not a hawk. He’s also not a dove. He’s, first, second and last, a Republican. His views on monetary policy quite clearly depend not on economic conditions, but on the party that occupies the White House. And his public remarks in 2010 were entirely incoherent. They declared that the Fed should take its cues from market reactions. But not like… what markets actually say, but what Warsh imagines they should say. Which is why in 2010 he was yelling for tighter money because he thought that markets should be warning of coming inflation (even though they were actually doing entirely the opposite). Which makes him entirely unsuited for the role.

Jerry Kopensky's avatar

Love this piece, Claudia!

IMO, the major problem with ANY Trump appointee for ANY position is his DEMAND of loyalty pledges to him, and him alone. Those pledges would supersede any/all historical postures and sentiments of those appointees.

In the case of the Fed, perhaps the most important INDEPENDENT agency, this as you state, is problematic. Any pledge of total allegiance to Trump renders the Fed Chair a puppet to the irrational whims and disastrous decisions of an authoritarian dictator.

This could render America an equivalent of a banana republic.

Jeff Carlon's avatar

Neil Dutta agrees with you he made a comment that of all the mentioned candidates that Trump picked the worst candidate based at his time at the Fed. Also, makes one wonder if he sold his soul to the president based on his prior hawkishness.

Marko Bjegovic's avatar

Appreciate your thoughts, Claudia. I actually think Warsh may not be as bad as many fear.

https://arkominaresearch.substack.com/p/my-thoughts-on-kevin-warsh

MMB-PHX's avatar

My hope is that Chairman Powell continues to stay on board and that he never hesitates to speak the truth, as he has in the past, to those on the FOMC who choose to bow to the miserably incompetent administration of "his horror."

Brent Jacobson's avatar

Considering his term will be up before Trump leaves office (assuming the worst) anyhow, I wouldn’t blame him for walking away. He’s been through hell.

Austin Orth's avatar

As a layperson, I've been struggling to understand the implications of Warsh's nomination. This helped a lot! Thanks!!

Richard Berner's avatar

Claudia, as you and others have emphasized, the Chair gets one vote on the FOMC. But I think his or her leadership role is at least equally important. This is a committee divided. Leadership is needed to achieve a decision on policy - not necessarily a consensus but one that respectfully bridges gaps. I agree with Don Kohn that some of Kevin Warsh's criticisms of the Fed are valid, but don't approve of the caustic tone with which they have been delivered. That does not evince the kind of leadership needed to succeed as Chair.

kbaa's avatar

> Given President Trump’s unprecedented efforts to pressure the Fed to lower interest rates, anyone who got the nomination would be under some suspicion.<

Did Warsh already sign an undated letter of resignation? Someone should ask him that during his confirmation hearing…

Ajay Patel's avatar

Thanks for the great insight.

Phil's avatar

This is a great summary of historical insights into Warsh to help develop a thesis on how he may govern the Fed if he makes it thru the senate confirmation hearings. I spent alot of time this weekend looking at his 'talk' to go along with my exploration of Bessent. I believe that there could be two main things that got him nominated by Trump (and Bessent) and you highlight the subtle one here...1) he believes the Fed funds rate is too high/restrictive and will work to bring it down to 2-3%, 2) he believes the Fed should get out of the way and let the treasury, President and Congress drive the economy with their larger, more appropriate fiscal mechanisms. I believe this second item you highlight in this post is critical to Bessent and Trump as they want to set policy and direction without interference. I expect his talk of reducing the balance sheet will be similar to Bessent's negative view of Yellen issuing T-bills instead of duration but when Bessent took Yellen's chair it was quickly apparent to him that 'oh, that is the right thing to do given the circumstances'...I expect Warsh to have the same 'findings' if/when he takes the chair and will continue the 'not QE, QE'. We shall see but the Senate confirmation hearings will be fun to listen to!

JV's avatar

I propose the fed should have a strategic yacht reserve so the next time unemployment rises unacceptably every billionaire would get a yacht sized in proportion to their wealth

Jim Jubak's avatar

For investors, what’s really scary about this is the kind of low-frequency disaster that Warsh might inflict during a market or economic meltdown is exactly the kind of scenario that the market is really bad at pricing in. But then again no one is hedging much of any thing negative right now, the options numbers say.

ScottB's avatar

Thanks for a very even-handed assessment. I just sent you a Warsh cartoon from 2007.

Curt R Stauffer's avatar

Warsh’s father-in-law is a fellow billionaire friend of the President. It is not a stretch, given the President’s cabinet choices, to believe that having a father-in-law who is a multi-billionaire friend of the President played a role in the choice. Just sayin!

Winston Smith London Oceania's avatar

Especially if he "invests" a few million in $KingMAGAcoin.

ADIL SAYEED's avatar

Ronald Lauder is also responsible for suggesting to his buddy Trump that acquisition of Greenland should be a US objective. As Fed Chair, Lauder son-in-law Warsh may play large role in deciding in which Fed district Greenland should be placed. New York (2nd district) would seem logical unless Trump is angry at New York Fed President Williams for not following Warsh's lead.

Bob Roberts's avatar

The 'hawk' label is a conveniently fictional confirmation fig leaf lending cover for adding a compliant policy stooge to aid and abet further US dollar debasement.