Stay-At-Home Macro (SAHM)

Share this post

All eyes are on the Fed, now more than ever

stayathomemacro.substack.com

All eyes are on the Fed, now more than ever

The Fed faces a tough decision on whether to raise interest rates against the backdrop of banks in turmoil and a country with high inflation. The message tomorrow will loom as large as the decision.

Claudia Sahm
Mar 21, 2023
33
13
Share
Share this post

All eyes are on the Fed, now more than ever

stayathomemacro.substack.com

Will the Fed raise the federal funds rate?

The Fed will likely raise rates by 25 basis points to 4.75%, but it might also pause its rate increases tomorrow. To some extent, the outcome depends on whether Jamie Dimon, the CEO of JP Morgan Chase, can steady First Republic Bank and if anything else shows up in the news cycle—good or bad—about the banks. The past few weeks have been up and down to which markets, banks, government officials, and depositors have reacted, greatly complicating the Fed’s job.

Twitter avatar for @WSJ
The Wall Street Journal @WSJ
Breaking: JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon is leading discussions with the chief executives of other big banks about fresh efforts to stabilize troubled First Republic Bank
on.wsj.comWSJ News Exclusive | JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon Leading Efforts to Craft New First Republic Bank Rescue PlanJPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon is leading discussions with the chief executives of other big banks about fresh efforts to stabilize troubled First Republic Bank.
4:05 PM ∙ Mar 20, 2023
122Likes40Retweets

Tomorrow the Fed should explain how many basis points of the federal funds rate it estimates are equivalent to the bank failures. That would give us a better sense of how much tightening the Fed is doing with its rate decision tomorrow paired with the banking turmoil. It’s impossible to know with any precision. It is almost surely more than 50 basis points. As a result, even 25 basis points from the Fed would be, taken together, a large move. A pause would still allow notable tightening, of course, how much depends on the effects of the bank failures.

I am in favor of pausing the rate increases tomorrow. I am not using bank failures as a new excuse to pause the rate hikes for the sake of workers. I have also been vocal since last fall that the Fed going so hard and fast—especially after the three 75 basis point hikes in a row—would “break” something in financial markets:

Twitter avatar for @Claudia_Sahm
Claudia Sahm @Claudia_Sahm
The Fed should clearly pause. Its rapid and large rate hikes are working. But it won’t pause. My forecast: 75, 50, 25. Unless something in US financial markets break then 0. lender of last resort > dual mandate. Buckle up.
Twitter avatar for @vtg2
Victoria Guida @vtg2
“A national collapse in home values is likely.” https://t.co/WlXEpBmoCW
1:21 PM ∙ Oct 19, 2022
123Likes12Retweets

So here we are. I was not the only one who predicted it, and it’s here. The Fed prides itself on being “data-driven.” Silicon Valley Bank, Signature Bank, Silvergate, and First Republic Bank are four important data points that outweigh any data on inflation and the labor market since the last meeting.

Share

What about in May and the coming meetings?

Regardless of the rate decision tomorrow, the Fed will clearly signal that inflation is too high, and more rate increases will likely be necessary. It will affirm that the federal funds will remain high as long as it takes for inflation to come down. It might be overshadowed tomorrow, but the Fed will continue to underscore the importance to people of getting inflation down, while acknowledging the pain for workers:

Stay-At-Home Macro (SAHM)
What could Fed Chair Jay Powell say to the 2 million people likely to be unemployed?
Earlier this week, Senator Elizabeth Warren pushed Fed Chair Jay Powell on what he would say to the two million workers the Fed expects will lose their jobs to get inflation down. It was a testy exchange. Powell’s frustration was fair, as was Warren’s…
Read more
3 months ago · 60 likes · 42 comments · Claudia Sahm

The Fed won’t bring too much attention—it’s premature—to the fact that if the banking worsens or contagion arises in other financial markets, the Fed may need to step in and cut rates, albeit as a last resort. Lending facilities are the front line, but they may not be enough. It too soon to say, but the Fed has the tools.

Stay-At-Home Macro (SAHM)
A Fed tale as old as time ...
The tale of Silicon Valley Bank and its fallout is still being written, and yet, it’s a story we know all too well. In fact, banking crises are at the heart of the Fed’s origin story. We may talk endlessly about monetary policy. And I can assure you that 25 versus 50 basis points and the…
Read more
2 months ago · 49 likes · 33 comments · Claudia Sahm

Inflation is bad; an unstable financial system is worse.

What will the dot plot say?

I do not expect to see the dot plot—the projections of the federal funds rate by each FOMC participant—or any part of the Summary of Economic Projections on Wednesday. If it shows up, ignore it. I have longstanding concerns about the dot plot; above all, it confuses people more than it clears up.

Stay-At-Home Macro (SAHM)
It's time for the 'dot plot' to go.
Tomorrow the Federal Open Market Committee will announce its latest decision on how much to support the economic recovery. Some will be watching closely, including analysts and traders on Wall Street; wealthy investors; Fed journalists; and a small group like me who simply LOVE the Fed. Chances are you won’t watch. I don’t blame you. The Fed doesn’t t…
Read more
2 years ago · 9 likes · 4 comments · Claudia Sahm

The last thing we need now is more confusion. Plus, every forecast blew up with Silicon Valley Bank. The FOMC participants have had other more pressing issues than updating their dot plot, which would be near impossible anyway.

Will inflation turn down notably soon?

Yes, by the summer. There are signs already of relief coming.

That’s when the shelter inflation will slow. (It’s less important in PCE (the Fed’s target) than CPI, but it is important.) Wage growth is slowing already, which, according to the Fed, should slow services ex housing inflation. Corporations are going to cool it with margins. Banking turmoil is taking away excuses to keep raising prices so fast, as their input costs inflation is easing.

Also, on the slowing demand, the Fed’s large, rapid interest rate hikes are showing through broadly to credit standards and borrowing costs. And that was before the banking turmoil. I am increasingly worried about a recession in the second half of this year. This summer, we will have a brief shining moment with inflation coming down and before millions start losing jobs.

Share

In closing

The Fed faces a tough decision, arguably in the toughest in many years. All eyes are on them to sift through the banking mayhem of the past few weeks and the stubbornly inflation of the past few years. Also, where are we headed? What the story?

The Fed’s effect on the economy and psychology is real. Godspeed.

Twitter avatar for @Claudia_Sahm
Claudia Sahm @Claudia_Sahm
"More broadly, the Fed’s decision on Wednesday is likely to have implications in terms of psychology," said Claudia Sahm.
qz.comThe Fed is about to meet—and economists remain very much split on the prospect for a rate hikeThe Fed will meet this week to decide on interest rates as the fight against inflation collides with banking turmoil
11:09 AM ∙ Mar 21, 2023

In the paid-only post later this week, I will analyze the tightening in the banking sector.

If you enjoyed today’s post, please subscribe to receive future ones in your inbox. Paid subscriptions are greatly appreciated.

33
13
Share
Share this post

All eyes are on the Fed, now more than ever

stayathomemacro.substack.com
13 Comments
Peter Paul Santa Ana
Writes Peter’s Newsletter
Mar 21Liked by Claudia Sahm

Much appreciated. A pause would be ideal.

Expand full comment
Reply
Beachman
Writes Beachman’s Newsletter
Mar 21Liked by Claudia Sahm

I think it is less important whether they raise by 0.25% or pause. It is more important to pay attention to their message, the data and their tone. Rebuilding confidence is their #1 priority tomorrow. Tackling inflation is well underway and many investors (even consumers) are seeing the forward lower trending CPI and PPI. Even labor is bound to come down given the tightening credit conditions among regional banks/local smaller banks because they serve SMBs.

Expand full comment
Reply
11 more comments…
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Claudia Sahm
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing