81 Comments
User's avatar
John Van Gundy's avatar

Walsh seems to be performing a good impression of Chauncey Gardner in the movie “Being There.”

“Whatever the Fed decides next week, hike or hold, we deserve a good explanation. I don’t particularly mind going into an FOMC meeting uncertain of the outcome, but I have zero tolerance for leaving a presser uncertain of why the Fed did what it did. The July FOMC statement, Warsh’s presser, and even to some extent the FOMC minutes left many questions about the hold unresolved. If the majority of the Fed remains confident that inflation is going back to 2% soon, I want to hear it; if not, it’s time to take action to restore that confidence.” — Claudia Sahm

ADIL SAYEED's avatar

Great point by Dr. Sahm about Summary of Economic Projections (SEP) being a useful exercise for formulating a view about how to make the interest rate decision.

Cleveland Fed nowcasters projecting that monthly core PCE rates will be 0.27% for August and 0,28% for September. So, as Dr. Sahm says, little sign of PCE inflation coming back to 2% any time soon.

If FOMC does not raise rate at this September meeting coming up, it will be more difficult for them to raise the rate at their October 27-28 meeting just before the mid-term elections. I know that they are not supposed to think about politics, but it would be hard not to do so.

I'm still inclined to wait and see with Fed rate unchanged, but that's a gut feeling without Dr. Sahm's experience in this field.

Jerry Kopensky's avatar

Insightful as always, Dr Sahm. It seems that inflationary impacts from the illegal war may be approaching a pivotal level.

The leadership of Iran seems to have made it quite clear that they have no interest in negotiating the end of the war unless and until Trump is no longer in office. Iran feels more enabled than previously.

If the anticipated blue tsunami occurs, Trump will be impeached, successfully this time. During this process, the power and influence of Trump will essentially be disabled which opens the portal to, not only a quick and favorable end to this war (and its inflationary impacts), but also revocation of these insane tariffs. Thoughts welcome from thread participants.

John Evans-Klock's avatar

The chances of conviction after impeachment are very small. I can imagine Trump doing something crazy enough for his party to turn on him, but it hasn’t happened yet in the craziest administration the country has ever seen.

Barry Grau's avatar

Beyond the unlikelihood of conviction following impeachment, a weakened Trump is more unpredictable and more dangerous.

Richard Daskin cfa cfp(r)'s avatar

I other words the fomc should not be the "sorcerer's apprentice"

Tw's avatar

awesome article

Alan F. Skrainka, CFA's avatar

The risk-management framing is the part I appreciate most, along with the willingness to say plainly that you moved. That is rarer in this business than it should be. The gasoline pass-through point is the one I keep returning to, because it is slow and easy to underweight when the energy headline itself feels like the whole story.

Staven's avatar

You are persuasive as always. I fear Warsh and the Trumpists are not actually persuadable by the data.

Disraeli's avatar

*Political* risk management: hikes will remain improbable unless and until Trump loses control of Congress in the mid-terms affording the G.O.P. the opportunity of shifting blame for further inflation pressures and hiking pains on Communists, er, Democrats. The recent job number over-performance lacks credibility, and Warsh will continue to quietly do as he's told (little, or nothing substantive.)

Alan Neff's avatar

I just read your Bloomberg piece per the link above. Well done. I completely agree with your view on timing Fed rate decisions to the data and nothing else, especially the whims of the Current Occupant of the White House.

Disraeli's avatar

I quite agree, professional risk management would indicate a hike is necessary. Instead we have a 'weather vane' that doesn't squeak. It's going to require an awful lot of Miracle-Gro to get us out of this dilemma.

Disraeli's avatar

I appreciate Ms. Sahm's reasoned and experienced technical analysis, even as facts on the ground change - that's the nature of the beast. Complaining that technical analysis isn't useful on an accomplished economist's blog is ... odd. Save the brickbats for Reddit.

Devon | Monthly Momentum's avatar

Claudia, respectfully, you are ignoring the elephant in the room which was the election. Trump used every means at his disposal to get his man as chair and Warsh will deliver his end of the deal. No analysis is useful without this context.

Claudia Sahm's avatar

See my Bloomberg Opinion piece. Link above. Warsh came into his role under the usual process: the President nominates, and the Senate confirms. Powell served out his full term. Warsh only has one vote of twelve.

Paul OBrien's avatar

Does the Fed need all those risk management arguments, or is it better to just to point out that inflation has been above target for years and the economy is doing fine? In politics they say that "if you are explaining you are losing." The American public believes inflation is too high. They are right. The Fed's job is to deliver low inflation. Raise rates next week.

Claudia Sahm's avatar

The Fed targets the inflation rate, not the price level, so bygones are bygones by design: policy is set on where inflation is heading, not on making up for where it's been. If the Fed hiked because of 65 months above target, that would be price-level targeting through the back door, a regime change nobody has voted on. The past matters only through the outlook, mainly by wearing down expectations, and that's exactly the honest form of the argument: the long stretch above target raises the stakes on the risks ahead, which is why I made a risk case rather than a scorecard case. And a scorecard has no stopping rule; "years above target" argued just as loudly for hikes in 2024 while inflation was falling fast, which is how you tighten into a slowdown. Also, whatever the Fed does, it must explain itself.

Paul OBrien's avatar

Very fair points. I was trying to separate the "inside baseball" arguments, which are very fair, from broader public communication. The risk factor discussion should take place in the Board room. But the broader public won't get it. Public perception of the central bank does depend on past outcomes and actions. Raising rates because inflation is too high is all the explanation the public needs and would be the best way to resist the inevitable blowback from you-know-who.

Gene Frenkle's avatar

Prices were too high at the beginning of 2008 and the Fed was slashing rates. Hemming and hawing is a sign that conditions aren’t that bad and the Fed doesn’t want to do something that weakens the economy.

Btw, I wonder if the Fed could make a mistake that strengthens the economy?? I would argue we got lucky in 2022 with a relatively low deficit ratio. I would argue deficit ratio is now the most important metric because it informs one of the strength of the economy as a recession jacks up the ratio. I would take under 2% GDP growth with a 3% deficit ratio like in 2016 over 2.9% GDP growth with a near 4% deficit ratio like in 2018.

Ray Noack's avatar

It seems we have only 2 choices

Restructuring the debt as Jeffrey Grundlach suggests or inflate our way out .

We will of course inflate away the debt.

Grundlach’s idea is better though since a soft default will drive away bond buyers and so force Congress to “ get religion “ on spending .

As a footnote , Grundlach runs 100 Billion and has been switching most long bonds to 1% coupon … so he must think the chances are not zero that it happens .

He continually holds up a mortgage bond prospectus and rants about how in 2008 the government simply changed all the rules …broke the law . Voided a contract…Why ? ..because they could But that was 2008 . They would never do that again ,right ?

My own back of envelope inflation is about 6% or about the growth of the money supply .

I am relieved though that the 22% rise in my home insurance is NOT inflation [ BLS) and that my IPhone has more Pixels ( demonic adjustment) .

Claudia Sahm's avatar

On inflating away the debt: my case for a hike is partly that the Fed is showing it won't go down that road. That commitment isn't declared once; it's made at meetings like next week's. On your 6%: the gap between measured inflation and lived costs is real, and insurance is a fair example. The CPI handles homeowners' insurance poorly, which is one reason I work from PCE, where it's included, though only net of claims. But investors with real money at stake price future inflation near 2.5%, not 6, and money growth hasn't tracked inflation well in decades. If inflation were truly 6%, the bond market would be the first to riot.

Ray Noack's avatar

Thanks for responding .

Yeah , You are spot on . The bond market would riot .

Thanks for providing a “ no spin “ zone on all things Fed related .

I value your take and understanding. I am skilled at buying individual common stock but not in economics and the workings of the Fed etc .

Thanks Claudia

Claudia Sahm's avatar

Always worth reading Galbraith. We share the starting point: this inflation is mostly due to supply shocks, and the Fed can't fix their causes, but that's the hold case I held all year. My post explains why I no longer think it's enough: the risks are feeding through to breadth, pass-through, and expectations, which rates do reach.

Lenny Goldberg's avatar

I'm surprised you didn't mention the rise in long-term Treasury rates, which reflects inflation expectations and arguably the Fed's potential failure to act, as a reason to raise rates, that is, to take the step the bond market is worried about. Perhaps not, you're the most reliable expert and hopefully next fed chair..

Claudia Sahm's avatar

Fair question. I anchored my case in the inflation data and risks rather than market prices because the long end is hard to read cleanly: the recent rise mixes expectations of Fed hikes, term premium, productivity, and fiscal supply, and you can't cleanly separate 'markets fear inflation' from 'markets expect the Fed to act.' There's also a circularity problem with hiking: long rates rose, and part of why is that markets think hikes are coming. That said, your instinct and mine point the same way: if the bond market is pricing in Fed action against these inflation risks, the most straightforward path is for the Fed to validate it, since a hike delivered calms the long end.

Jeffrey L Kaufman's avatar

Notably, the president's name is not mentioned in this missive. We know the Fed Board has the courage to do what is necessary, but how does the threat of huge invective that would come from the president in the face of a rate hike affect decisions, especially Warsh's position, which is new and perhaps vulnerable?

Claudia Sahm's avatar

See my reply to Disraeli above. There's a link to my new Bloomberg Opinion piece on why the Fed should ignore the midterms (and politics in general) in its rate decisions.

Nancy Kimelman's avatar

You rightly argue that inflation is high due in large part to Ai, oil and tariffs. And these forces are not letting up. But is monetary policy the solution to inflation not driven by monetary forces? That is still the big question,

Claudia Sahm's avatar

The Fed's target is 2% regardless of the source of inflation. Supply-driven inflation earns patience in the first round, and the Fed has given it: that was the case for holding all year. But monetary policy is what keeps supply shocks from turning into second-round effects through expectations and pass-through, and after nearly five years above 2%, patience has to have a limit. My case is about the second round, not the first.

Bob Adolph's avatar

Thank you for your very thoughtful analysis. I also agree - time to hike.

One more strong reason to hike: Trump’s constant chaos.

While many of his actions are one time transients, he doesn’t let up. His continuing injection of inflationary actions results in a nearly steady stimulus for inflation. That requires an opposing action (hikes) to compensate.

Claudia Sahm's avatar

There's a version of your chaos point that's core to my case: one supply shock is transitory, but a steady sequence of them isn't—the 'one-time' label stops applying when new shocks keep arriving, which is exactly why I flagged more tariffs as a live risk rather than treating last year's as finished business. The Fed can't offset any single shock, but it can't wave through an endless series of them either.

Jcarlet's avatar

Rate hike delayed until December then big hike.